More Reputation Inconsistencies

[Fireflyb 920]

[14:01:43] <Cobb> i'm targeting you guys but it's not going Enemy

[14:01:54] <Nosfirebird> not on [perimeter]

[14:02:31] <Nosfirebird> i have to be on the perim to go enemy

 

[14:03:38] <Nosfirebird> and are u aprt of crater edge?  <-- deed they were catapulting into

[14:03:44] <Cobb> alliance

[14:03:51] <Nosfirebird> that would be why

 

Wtf? 

 

So if a deed in my alliance is being attacked, I can't target the people (with active Templars ofc etc., and them on KOS) in order to threaten them off via my White Knight Reputation Justice?

 

http://forum.wurmonline.com/index.php?/topic/84825-please-remove-all-the-anti-pvp-rules-on-the-epic-cluster/

[thorlor 50]

How come he wasn't hunted? Wasn't he cata'ing the deed?

 

edit: typooo

Edited July 23, 2013 by thorlor

[Fireflyb 920]

How come he wasn't hunted? Wasn't he cata'ing the deed?

 

edit: typooo

 

If you kill all the Templars and catapult, you don't go Hunted or lose rep afaik.

[thorlor 50]

Didn't he go hunted for killing the templars?

[Fireflyb 920]

Didn't he go hunted for killing the templars?

 

You don't go hunted for attacking Templars of a deed; it puts you on KOS, but you don't lose rep or go hunted.  just makes you "Enemy".

[thorlor 50]

Lol. So you basically can't stop someone of the same kingdom from raiding the deed without going hunted yourself?

[Maxthx 641]

Lol. So you basically can't stop someone of the same kingdom from raiding the deed without going hunted yourself?

 

Yup.

[Radni 1,089]

That's just wrong.

[nosfirebird 193]

Yup.

no ppl from the village are able to attack without going hunted i posted a thread about tactus attacking me and not going hunted and then i killed him and i went hunted

[Klaa 4,872]

Should go both Hunted and loss reputation for killing deed guards, let alone attacking them to begin with.

[Kagrenac 812]

Should go both Hunted and loss reputation for killing deed guards, let alone attacking them to begin with.

Except since he is KOS on the deed, the guards attacked him first.

You shouldn't lose rep for defending yourself.

[Sir Arowhun 473]

Alright Rolf, I can't see any good solutions to this now. Remove the hunted system, or add some sort of feudal alliance system similar to PMKs. We are all getting tired of this nonsense.

[Klaa 4,872]

Except since he is KOS on the deed, the guards attacked him first.

You shouldn't lose rep for defending yourself.

 

True there could be cases of someone using KoS to grief. Okay, he gets rep loss and goes Hunted if guards die ON the deed. Offdeed, its fine to defend.

 

Or the first one or two guards just makes you go Hunted, kill another and its rep loss.

[godcomplex 63]

Except since he is KOS on the deed, the guards attacked him first.

You shouldn't lose rep for defending yourself.

 

Defending himself lol thats why he bought a catapult along...