Posted August 26, 2012 Hello,as a real life spearman I would like to emphasize the role of polearms in wurm.Historically spears were the most used weapon due to multiple reasons- easy to manufacture- very effective even in untrained hands.(In my first spear practice I stood against a man who was practicing with sword and shield for about a year already, I was getting through his defences in about 75% of tries)- only effective defence against cavalry (already implemented in wurm)- have long reach - i. e. user is somewhat safe- can be used with shields.Now if you imagine a formation of spearmen with short spears (approx 1.5 meter), two lines would suffice.First line can attack the enemies that are in two tile's distance in front of it, the second line can attack the enemies that are just in front of the first line.This means that both lines can focus their attack on single line, or that second line attacks the first enemies' line. (still the first enemy line has to be careful not to get hurt from the both lines, which are potentially threatening it).I don't think that formations are possible to implement in Wurm though.What I think that may be possible is to give spears different range - good range being with one tile gap between you and enemy.Also what I would like to suggest is that some spears have shields equippable as well (are either one handed or have one handed / two handed mode, with different attributes).Two handed spears should have also other means of damaging enemies besides piercing. (Tested, heavier spears tend to knock out people in real life if you swing them into a helmet, even gently, - very similar to pole axes).I hope at least part of these suggestions are implementable.Kind Regards,Eleri 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 26, 2012 Spears should be completely menacing to mountable animals like (hell) horses, bulls, bears et cetera. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 26, 2012 In fact they should be menacing against everything as far as you don't let it get close enough (two handed use) - which could be solved by putting effective distance for spear a tile further.Only real weakness of a two handed spear user is an archer or a spearman with a shield. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 26, 2012 (edited) I agree with allowing spear users to wear shields. Although, probably not a large shield. I think they should be usable with small and medium shields, personally.Also, maybe lengthen the swing (stab) timer by 1 second when using a shield? Edited August 26, 2012 by ianrose 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 26, 2012 · Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam im a 5 time world champion spearman Share this post Link to post
Posted August 26, 2012 · Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam im a 5 time world champion spearmanWon't be a 6th.. Share this post Link to post
Posted August 26, 2012 · Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - spam Because im the 6th Share this post Link to post
Posted August 26, 2012 Would be nice if spears would be effective while moving and keeping a 1 tile distance between you and your enemy. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 26, 2012 To add to your suggestion, Elen. May I suggest the High Guard. A stance used by Knights during, mainly the crusades, but was invented by the Romans. Using a longsword, it aimed to deal maximum damage to someone on horseback while the wielder was on foot, holding the sword above the head, ready to strike instantly down or up, causing the assailant to greatly reconsider his tactical approach and usually cutting beneath the left arm, causing not only loss of blood but loss of control of the horse.I think it was called The Guard of Hawk.Ah yes, La Poste De Falcone. that was its name, given such as it offered a solid stance against mounted opposition.Just an idea. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 27, 2012 I would like to point out, that if a spear's optimum reach is placed 1 tile away, then the spear should preform incredibly poorly in close range. (Possibly becoming defensive or impossible to use. Close range melee VS long range melee.)Atm, most mobs will attempt to follow you, but not always to close the gap.Also... AI suggests that the mobs would think of a better way to attack vs your weapon. Atm spiders, wolves, and bears ignore me until I initiate combat. But they love to attack my well equipped, low fs, high priest alt. Therefore I do think some form of rudimentary AI already exists.In the case of a mob seeing you holding a long spear, I think bears should consider running mid fight, spiders should try to flank you constantly, and scorpions should clamp on to your spear and take it, closing one of their pincer attacks. Possibly dropping it later, or snapping it in half if the scorpion is aged, otherwise just causing dmg to the spear. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 27, 2012 to Kamikazi:I have to admit that your anti spear attacks are a viable idea. Again, it is spearman's duty to keep his tool intact. Although I think that animals would rarely assault the weapon (especially scorpions and spiders) instead of user, I'd rather consider it a PvP option.As far as poor close range performance is considered, I would limit it till 50 skill with two handed spear use, as there are many emergency techniques that are very effective at close range. (and you can always decide to hold the spear in the middle instead of first third of the pole).to Lancelot:High guard is fine, but again every stabbing weapon has it. A second line spearman would use it in tight formations as he has little space anywhere else. The main problem with using a short weapon against cavalry is that cavalry has far much more energy - imagine that a horseman is 500 kg hammer riding at you at sixty kilometers per hour, you won't be waiting with a longsword till it gets near. (especially if the horseman is spearman and will get opportunity to hit you first)- Also it would be nice if you defined which terminology you use. Longsword may mean the one-handed weapon-as in game, or the weapon that English usually refer to as Bastard sword, but s also called longsword as a translation of german langschwert http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Langschwert.to Darthryan:Yes there are still people who are practicing with middle age weapons, in middle age armour, and gathering up for battles. You can check this video if you need proof./>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u0oeN1XyYEgit is an annual battle in Northern Poland. There are many "battles" occuring in central Europe, Wolin is one of the bigger ones.to Ianrose:Spears were commonly used even with kite shields as you can see in this picture http://www.hurstwic.org/history/articles/manufacturing/pix/kite_shield.jpg Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 27, 2012 Lol ^As for spears/pole arms, I never see them being used, much like small axes etc. would be nice if Rolf spent some actual time into balancing all the weps, so that each are all viable to use. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted August 27, 2012 · Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - OT Hidden by KaiH, September 1, 2012 - OT small axes are amazing Share this post Link to post